Quiet pipeline emails

1. Never send a pipeline email to anyone other than the user who created
   the pipeline.
2. Only send pipeline success emails to people with the custom
   notification setting for enabled. Watchers and participants will
   never receive this.
3. When custom settings are unset (for new settings and legacy ones),
   act as if failed_pipeline is set.

app/models/ci/pipeline.rb

@@ -164,11 +164,6 @@ module Ci
       builds.latest.with_artifacts_not_expired.includes(project: [:namespace])
     end
 
-    # For now the only user who participates is the user who triggered
-    def participants(_current_user = nil)
-      Array(user)
-    end
-
     def valid_commit_sha
       if self.sha == Gitlab::Git::BLANK_SHA
         self.errors.add(:sha, " cant be 00000000 (branch removal)")

app/models/notification_setting.rb

@@ -60,16 +60,25 @@ class NotificationSetting < ActiveRecord::Base
   def set_events
     return if custom?
 
-    EMAIL_EVENTS.each do |event|
-      events[event] = false
-    end
+    self.events = {}
   end
 
   # Validates store accessors values as boolean
   # It is a text field so it does not cast correct boolean values in JSON
   def events_to_boolean
     EMAIL_EVENTS.each do |event|
-      events[event] = ActiveRecord::ConnectionAdapters::Column::TRUE_VALUES.include?(events[event])
+      bool = ActiveRecord::ConnectionAdapters::Column::TRUE_VALUES.include?(public_send(event))
+
+      events[event] = bool
     end
   end
+
+  # Allow people to receive failed pipeline notifications if they already have
+  # custom notifications enabled, as these are more like mentions than the other
+  # custom settings.
+  def failed_pipeline
+    bool = super
+
+    bool.nil? || bool
+  end
 end

app/services/notification_recipient_service.rb

@@ -12,11 +12,7 @@ class NotificationRecipientService
     custom_action = build_custom_key(action, target)
 
     recipients = target.participants(current_user)
-
-    unless NotificationSetting::EXCLUDED_WATCHER_EVENTS.include?(custom_action)
     recipients = add_project_watchers(recipients)
-    end
-
     recipients = add_custom_notifications(recipients, custom_action)
     recipients = reject_mention_users(recipients)
 
@@ -43,6 +39,28 @@ class NotificationRecipientService
     recipients.uniq
   end
 
+  def build_pipeline_recipients(target, current_user, action:)
+    return [] unless current_user
+
+    custom_action =
+      case action.to_s
+      when 'failed'
+        :failed_pipeline
+      when 'success'
+        :success_pipeline
+      end
+
+    notification_setting = notification_setting_for_user_project(current_user, target.project)
+
+    return [] if notification_setting.mention? || notification_setting.disabled?
+
+    return [] if notification_setting.custom? && !notification_setting.public_send(custom_action)
+
+    return [] if (notification_setting.watch? || notification_setting.participating?) && NotificationSetting::EXCLUDED_WATCHER_EVENTS.include?(custom_action)
+
+    reject_users_without_access([current_user], target)
+  end
+
   def build_relabeled_recipients(target, current_user, labels:)
     recipients = add_labels_subscribers([], target, labels: labels)
     recipients = reject_unsubscribed_users(recipients, target)
@@ -290,4 +308,16 @@ class NotificationRecipientService
   def build_custom_key(action, object)
     "#{action}_#{object.class.model_name.name.underscore}".to_sym
   end
+
+  def notification_setting_for_user_project(user, project)
+    project_setting = user.notification_settings_for(project)
+
+    return project_setting unless project_setting.global?
+
+    group_setting = user.notification_settings_for(project.group)
+
+    return group_setting unless group_setting.global?
+
+    user.global_notification_setting
+  end
 end

app/services/notification_service.rb

@@ -278,11 +278,11 @@ class NotificationService
 
     return unless mailer.respond_to?(email_template)
 
-    recipients ||= NotificationRecipientService.new(pipeline.project).build_recipients(
+    recipients ||= NotificationRecipientService.new(pipeline.project).build_pipeline_recipients(
       pipeline,
       pipeline.user,
       action: pipeline.status,
-      skip_current_user: false).map(&:notification_email)
+    ).map(&:notification_email)
 
     if recipients.any?
       mailer.public_send(email_template, pipeline, recipients).deliver_later

app/views/shared/notifications/_custom_notifications.html.haml

@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@
                   .form-group
                     .checkbox{ class: ("prepend-top-0" if index == 0) }
                       %label{ for: field_id }
-                        = check_box("notification_setting", event, id: field_id, class: "js-custom-notification-event", checked: notification_setting.events[event])
+                        = check_box("notification_setting", event, id: field_id, class: "js-custom-notification-event", checked: notification_setting.public_send(event))
                         %strong
                           = notification_event_name(event)
                           = icon("spinner spin", class: "custom-notification-event-loading")

changelogs/unreleased/quiet-pipelines.yml

+---
+title: Only email pipeline creators; only email for successful pipelines with custom
+  settings
+merge_request:
+author:

doc/workflow/notifications.md

@@ -66,14 +66,13 @@ Below is the table of events users can be notified of:
 In all of the below cases, the notification will be sent to:
 - Participants:
   - the author and assignee of the issue/merge request
-  - the author of the pipeline
   - authors of comments on the issue/merge request
   - anyone mentioned by `@username` in the issue/merge request title or description
   - anyone mentioned by `@username` in any of the comments on the issue/merge request
 
     ...with notification level "Participating" or higher
 
-- Watchers: users with notification level "Watch" (however successful pipeline would be off for watchers)
+- Watchers: users with notification level "Watch"
 - Subscribers: anyone who manually subscribed to the issue/merge request
 - Custom: Users with notification level "custom" who turned on notifications for any of the events present in the table below
 
@@ -89,8 +88,8 @@ In all of the below cases, the notification will be sent to:
 | Reopen merge request   | |
 | Merge merge request    | |
 | New comment            | The above, plus anyone mentioned by `@username` in the comment, with notification level "Mention" or higher |
-| Failed pipeline        | The above, plus the author of the pipeline |
-| Successful pipeline    | The above, plus the author of the pipeline |
+| Failed pipeline        | The author of the pipeline |
+| Successful pipeline    | The author of the pipeline, if they have the custom notification setting for successful pipelines set |
 
 
 In addition, if the title or description of an Issue or Merge Request is

spec/factories/ci/pipelines.rb

@@ -48,6 +48,10 @@ FactoryGirl.define do
       trait :success do
         status :success
       end
+
+      trait :failed do
+        status :failed
+      end
     end
   end
 end

spec/models/ci/pipeline_spec.rb

@@ -1055,10 +1055,13 @@ describe Ci::Pipeline, models: true do
     end
 
     before do
-      reset_delivered_emails!
-
       project.team << [pipeline.user, Gitlab::Access::DEVELOPER]
 
+      pipeline.user.global_notification_setting.
+        update(level: 'custom', failed_pipeline: true, success_pipeline: true)
+
+      reset_delivered_emails!
+
       perform_enqueued_jobs do
         pipeline.enqueue
         pipeline.run

spec/services/notification_service_spec.rb

@@ -113,7 +113,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
         project.add_master(issue.assignee)
         project.add_master(note.author)
         create(:note_on_issue, noteable: issue, project_id: issue.project_id, note: '@subscribed_participant cc this guy')
-        update_custom_notification(:new_note, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:new_note, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:new_note, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -379,7 +379,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
         build_team(note.project)
         reset_delivered_emails!
         allow_any_instance_of(Commit).to receive(:author).and_return(@u_committer)
-        update_custom_notification(:new_note, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:new_note, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:new_note, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -457,7 +457,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
       add_users_with_subscription(issue.project, issue)
       reset_delivered_emails!
-      update_custom_notification(:new_issue, @u_guest_custom, project)
+      update_custom_notification(:new_issue, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
       update_custom_notification(:new_issue, @u_custom_global)
     end
 
@@ -567,7 +567,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#reassigned_issue' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:reassign_issue, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:reassign_issue, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:reassign_issue, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -760,7 +760,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#close_issue' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:close_issue, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:close_issue, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:close_issue, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -791,7 +791,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#reopen_issue' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:reopen_issue, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:reopen_issue, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:reopen_issue, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -856,14 +856,14 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
     before do
       build_team(merge_request.target_project)
       add_users_with_subscription(merge_request.target_project, merge_request)
-      update_custom_notification(:new_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, project)
+      update_custom_notification(:new_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
       update_custom_notification(:new_merge_request, @u_custom_global)
       reset_delivered_emails!
     end
 
     describe '#new_merge_request' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:new_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:new_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:new_merge_request, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -952,7 +952,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#reassigned_merge_request' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:reassign_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:reassign_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:reassign_merge_request, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -1026,7 +1026,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#closed_merge_request' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:close_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:close_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:close_merge_request, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -1056,7 +1056,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#merged_merge_request' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:merge_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:merge_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:merge_merge_request, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -1108,7 +1108,7 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
     describe '#reopen_merge_request' do
       before do
-        update_custom_notification(:reopen_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, project)
+        update_custom_notification(:reopen_merge_request, @u_guest_custom, resource: project)
         update_custom_notification(:reopen_merge_request, @u_custom_global)
       end
 
@@ -1281,40 +1281,172 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
   describe 'Pipelines' do
     describe '#pipeline_finished' do
       let(:project) { create(:project, :public, :repository) }
-      let(:current_user) { create(:user) }
       let(:u_member) { create(:user) }
-      let(:u_other) { create(:user) }
+      let(:u_watcher) { create_user_with_notification(:watch, 'watcher') }
+
+      let(:u_custom_notification_unset) do
+        create_user_with_notification(:custom, 'custom_unset')
+      end
+
+      let(:u_custom_notification_enabled) do
+        user = create_user_with_notification(:custom, 'custom_enabled')
+        update_custom_notification(:success_pipeline, user, resource: project)
+        update_custom_notification(:failed_pipeline, user, resource: project)
+        user
+      end
+
+      let(:u_custom_notification_disabled) do
+        user = create_user_with_notification(:custom, 'custom_disabled')
+        update_custom_notification(:success_pipeline, user, resource: project, value: false)
+        update_custom_notification(:failed_pipeline, user, resource: project, value: false)
+        user
+      end
 
       let(:commit) { project.commit }
-      let(:pipeline) do
-        create(:ci_pipeline, :success,
+
+      def create_pipeline(user, status)
+        create(:ci_pipeline, status,
                project: project,
-               user: current_user,
+               user: user,
                ref: 'refs/heads/master',
                sha: commit.id,
                before_sha: '00000000')
       end
 
       before do
-        project.add_master(current_user)
         project.add_master(u_member)
+        project.add_master(u_watcher)
+        project.add_master(u_custom_notification_unset)
+        project.add_master(u_custom_notification_enabled)
+        project.add_master(u_custom_notification_disabled)
+
         reset_delivered_emails!
       end
 
-      context 'without custom recipients' do
-        it 'notifies the pipeline user' do
+      context 'with a successful pipeline' do
+        context 'when the creator has default settings' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_member, :success)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'notifies nobody' do
+            should_not_email_anyone
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has watch set' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_watcher, :success)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'notifies nobody' do
+            should_not_email_anyone
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has custom notifications, but without any set' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_custom_notification_unset, :success)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'notifies nobody' do
+            should_not_email_anyone
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has custom notifications disabled' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_custom_notification_disabled, :success)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'notifies nobody' do
+            should_not_email_anyone
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has custom notifications enabled' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_custom_notification_enabled, :success)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'emails only the creator' do
+            should_only_email(u_custom_notification_enabled, kind: :bcc)
+          end
+        end
+      end
+
+      context 'with a failed pipeline' do
+        context 'when the creator has no custom notification set' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_member, :failed)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'emails only the creator' do
+            should_only_email(u_member, kind: :bcc)
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has watch set' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_watcher, :failed)
             notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
 
-          should_only_email(current_user, kind: :bcc)
+          it 'emails only the creator' do
+            should_only_email(u_watcher, kind: :bcc)
           end
         end
 
-      context 'with custom recipients' do
-        it 'notifies the custom recipients' do
-          users = [u_member, u_other]
-          notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline, users.map(&:notification_email))
+        context 'when the creator has custom notifications, but without any set' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_custom_notification_unset, :failed)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'emails only the creator' do
+            should_only_email(u_custom_notification_unset, kind: :bcc)
+          end
+        end
 
-          should_only_email(*users, kind: :bcc)
+        context 'when the creator has custom notifications disabled' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_custom_notification_disabled, :failed)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'notifies nobody' do
+            should_not_email_anyone
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has custom notifications set' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_custom_notification_enabled, :failed)
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'emails only the creator' do
+            should_only_email(u_custom_notification_enabled, kind: :bcc)
+          end
+        end
+
+        context 'when the creator has no read_build access' do
+          before do
+            pipeline = create_pipeline(u_member, :failed)
+            project.update(public_builds: false)
+            project.team.truncate
+            notification.pipeline_finished(pipeline)
+          end
+
+          it 'does not send emails' do
+            should_not_email_anyone
+          end
         end
       end
     end
@@ -1385,9 +1517,9 @@ describe NotificationService, services: true do
 
   # Create custom notifications
   # When resource is nil it means global notification
-  def update_custom_notification(event, user, resource = nil)
+  def update_custom_notification(event, user, resource: nil, value: true)
     setting = user.notification_settings_for(resource)
-    setting.events[event] = true
+    setting.events[event] = value
     setting.save
   end
 

spec/workers/pipeline_notification_worker_spec.rb

@@ -3,131 +3,19 @@ require 'spec_helper'
 describe PipelineNotificationWorker do
   include EmailHelpers
 
-  let(:pipeline) do
-    create(:ci_pipeline,
-           project: project,
-           sha: project.commit('master').sha,
-           user: pusher,
-           status: status)
-  end
-
-  let(:project) { create(:project, :repository, public_builds: false) }
-  let(:user) { create(:user) }
-  let(:pusher) { user }
-  let(:watcher) { pusher }
+  let(:pipeline) { create(:ci_pipeline) }
 
   describe '#execute' do
-    before do
-      reset_delivered_emails!
-      pipeline.project.team << [pusher, Gitlab::Access::DEVELOPER]
-    end
+    it 'calls NotificationService#pipeline_finished when the pipeline exists' do
+      expect(NotificationService).to receive_message_chain(:new, :pipeline_finished)
 
-    context 'when watcher has developer access' do
-      before do
-        pipeline.project.team << [watcher, Gitlab::Access::DEVELOPER]
-      end
-
-      shared_examples 'sending emails' do
-        it 'sends emails' do
-          perform_enqueued_jobs do
       subject.perform(pipeline.id)
     end
 
-          emails = ActionMailer::Base.deliveries
-          actual = emails.flat_map(&:bcc).sort
-          expected_receivers = receivers.map(&:email).uniq.sort
-
-          expect(actual).to eq(expected_receivers)
-          expect(emails.size).to eq(1)
-          expect(emails.last.subject).to include(email_subject)
-        end
-      end
-
-      context 'with success pipeline' do
-        let(:status) { 'success' }
-        let(:email_subject) { "Pipeline ##{pipeline.id} has succeeded" }
-        let(:receivers) { [pusher, watcher] }
-
-        it_behaves_like 'sending emails'
-
-        context 'with pipeline from someone else' do
-          let(:pusher) { create(:user) }
-          let(:watcher) { user }
-
-          context 'with success pipeline notification on' do
-            before do
-              watcher.global_notification_setting.
-                update(level: 'custom', success_pipeline: true)
-            end
-
-            it_behaves_like 'sending emails'
-          end
-
-          context 'with success pipeline notification off' do
-            let(:receivers) { [pusher] }
-
-            before do
-              watcher.global_notification_setting.
-                update(level: 'custom', success_pipeline: false)
-            end
-
-            it_behaves_like 'sending emails'
-          end
-        end
-
-        context 'with failed pipeline' do
-          let(:status) { 'failed' }
-          let(:email_subject) { "Pipeline ##{pipeline.id} has failed" }
-
-          it_behaves_like 'sending emails'
+    it 'does nothing when the pipeline does not exist' do
+      expect(NotificationService).not_to receive(:new)
 
-          context 'with pipeline from someone else' do
-            let(:pusher) { create(:user) }
-            let(:watcher) { user }
-
-            context 'with failed pipeline notification on' do
-              before do
-                watcher.global_notification_setting.
-                  update(level: 'custom', failed_pipeline: true)
-              end
-
-              it_behaves_like 'sending emails'
-            end
-
-            context 'with failed pipeline notification off' do
-              let(:receivers) { [pusher] }
-
-              before do
-                watcher.global_notification_setting.
-                  update(level: 'custom', failed_pipeline: false)
-              end
-
-              it_behaves_like 'sending emails'
-            end
-          end
-        end
-      end
-    end
-
-    context 'when watcher has no read_build access' do
-      let(:status) { 'failed' }
-      let(:email_subject) { "Pipeline ##{pipeline.id} has failed" }
-      let(:watcher) { create(:user) }
-
-      before do
-        pipeline.project.team << [watcher, Gitlab::Access::GUEST]
-
-        watcher.global_notification_setting.
-          update(level: 'custom', failed_pipeline: true)
-
-        perform_enqueued_jobs do
-          subject.perform(pipeline.id)
-        end
-      end
-
-      it 'does not send emails' do
-        should_only_email(pusher, kind: :bcc)
-      end
+      subject.perform(Ci::Pipeline.maximum(:id).to_i.succ)
     end
   end
 end