WL#4374 "Maria - force start if Recovery fails multiple times"

http://forge.mysql.com/worklog/task.php?id=4374
new option --maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures=N; number of consecutive recovery failures (failures
of log reading or recovery processing, anything in [translog_init(),maria_recovery_from_log()])
is stored in the control file; if at a Maria start they are more than N, logs are removed. This is for automated
systems which have to run whatever happens. As tables risk staying corrupted, --maria-recover should also
be used on them: this revision makes maria-recover work (it was disabled).
Fixed bug in translog_is_log_files(). translog_init() now prints message to error log if failed.
Removed \0 in the output of SHOW ENGINE MARIA LOGS; removed hard-coded engine name there.

KNOWN_BUGS.txt:
  As option --maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures is added, it corresponds to the wish "we should fix that if this happens etc".
  LOAD INDEX is not ignored since a few weeks. Listed concurrency bugs have been fixed some time ago.
  Recovery of fulltext and GIS indexes works since a few weeks.
mysql-test/include/maria_make_snapshot.inc:
  configurable prefix in table's name (so far 't' or 't_corrupted')
mysql-test/include/maria_make_snapshot_for_comparison.inc:
  configurable prefix in table's name (so far 't' or 't_corrupted')
mysql-test/include/maria_make_snapshot_for_feeding_recovery.inc:
  configurable prefix in table's name (so far 't' or 't_corrupted')
mysql-test/include/maria_verify_recovery.inc:
  configurable prefix in table's name (so far 't' or 't_corrupted')
mysql-test/lib/mtr_report.pl:
  new test maria-recover.test generates expected corruption warnings in the error log. maria-recovery.test's corrupted table is renamed to t_corrupted1 instead of t1.
mysql-test/r/maria-preload.result:
  result update. maria_pagecache_read* values are similar to the previous version of this file, though a bit bigger
  because using the information_schema and the join leads to some internal maria temp table being used, and thus some
  blocks of it being read.
mysql-test/r/maria-purge.result:
  engine's name in SHOW ENGINE MARIA LOGS changed.
mysql-test/r/maria-recover.result:
  result for new test. We see corruption messages at first SELECT and then none at second SELECT, expected.
mysql-test/r/maria-recovery.result:
  result update
mysql-test/r/maria.result:
  new variables show up
mysql-test/t/disabled.def:
  BUG#34911 is not fixed but the test had been made independent of the bug (workaround). A new bug (crash) has popped recently, so it has to stay
  disabled (BUG#35107).
mysql-test/t/maria-preload.test:
  Work around BUG#34911 "FLUSH STATUS doesn't flush what it should":
  compute differences in status variables before and after relevant queries
mysql-test/t/maria-recover-master.opt:
  test --maria-recover
mysql-test/t/maria-recover.test:
  Test of the --maria-recover option (build a corrupted table and see if it is auto-repaired)
mysql-test/t/maria-recovery-big.test:
  update for new API of include/maria*.inc
mysql-test/t/maria-recovery-bitmap.test:
  update for new API of include/maria*.inc
mysql-test/t/maria-recovery.test:
  update for new API of include/maria*.inc. Corrupted table t1 renamed to t_corrupted1, so that mtr_report.pl
  does not blindly remove all corruption messages for t1 which is
  a common name.
storage/maria/ha_maria.cc:
  Enabling maria-recover.
  Adding option and global variable --maria_force_start_after_recovery_failures: ha_maria_init()
  calls mark_recovery_start() and mark_recovery_success() to keep track of failed consecutive recoveries
  and remove logs if needed.
  Removed \0 in the output of SHOW ENGINE MARIA LOGS; removed hard-coded engine name there.
storage/maria/ma_checkpoint.c:
  new prototype
storage/maria/ma_control_file.c:
  Storing in one byte in the control file, the number of consecutive recovery failures.
storage/maria/ma_control_file.h:
  new prototype
storage/maria/ma_init.c:
  new prototype
storage/maria/ma_locking.c:
  Need to update open_count on disk at first write and close for transactional tables, like we already did for
  non-transactional tables, otherwise we cannot notice that the table is dubious.
storage/maria/ma_loghandler.c:
  translog_is_log_files() is made more generic to serve either to search or to delete logs (the latter is
  for --maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures). It also had a bug (always returned FALSE).
storage/maria/ma_loghandler.h:
  export function because ha_maria::mark_recovery_start() needs it
storage/maria/ma_recovery.c:
  changing name of maria_recover() to distinguish from the maria-recover option.
storage/maria/ma_recovery.h:
  changing name of maria_recover() to distinguish from the maria-recover option.
storage/maria/ma_test_force_start.pl:
  Test of --maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures (and also, to be realistic, of --maria-recover).
  This is standalone because mysql-test-run does not support testing that multiple mysqld restarts expectedly failed.
  I'll have to run it on my machine and also on a Windows machine.
storage/maria/unittest/ma_control_file-t.c:
  adding recovery_failures to the test
storage/maria/unittest/ma_test_loghandler_multigroup-t.c:
  fix for compiler warning (unused variable in non-debug build)

KNOWN_BUGS.txt

@@ -24,23 +24,9 @@ or in the worst case add it here for others to know!
 Known bugs that we are working on and will be fixed shortly
 ===========================================================
 
-- If the log files are damaged or inconsistent, Maria may fail to start.
-  We should fix that if this happens and mysqld is restarted (thanks to
-  mysqld_safe, instance manager or other script) it should disregard the
-  old logs, start anyway and automaticly repair any tables that was found
-  to be crashed on open.
-  Temporary fix is to remove or maria_log.???????? files from the data
-  directory, restart mysqld and run CHECK TABLE / REPAIR TABLE or 
-  mysqlcheck on your Maria tables
 - We have some instabilities in log writing that is under investigatation
   This causes mainly assert to triggers in the code and sometimes
   the log handler doesn't start up after restart.
-- LOAD INDEX commands are for the moment ignored for Maria tables
-  (The code needs to be rewritten to do all reads through page cache to
-  avoid half-block reads)
-- Some concurrency bugs in Maria's page cache which sometimes show up
-  under load http://bugs.mysql.com/bug.php?id=34161 and
-  http://bugs.mysql.com/bug.php?id=34634 .
 
 Known bugs that are planned to be fixed before Beta
 ===================================================
@@ -61,19 +47,15 @@ Known bugs that are planned to be fixed before Beta
 Missing features that is planned to fix before Beta
 ===================================================
 
-- We will add an maria-recover option to automaticly repair any
-  crashed tables on open. (This is needed for not transactional tables
-  and also in edge cases for transactional tables when the table
-  crashed because of a bug in  MySQL or Maria code)
 - Multiple concurrent inserts & multiple concurrent readers at same time
   with full MVCC control.  Note that UPDATE and DELETE will still be
   blocking (as with MyISAM)
 - COUNT(*) and TABLE CHECKSUM under MVCC (ie, they are instant and kept up
   to date even with multiple inserter)
-- Recovery of fulltext and GIS indexes.
 
 
 Features planned for future releases
 ====================================
 
 http://forge.mysql.com/worklog/
+(you can enter "maria" in the "quick search" field there).

mysql-test/include/maria_make_snapshot.inc

@@ -10,28 +10,29 @@
 # $mms_copy : to copy table from database to spare directory
 # $mms_reverse : to copy it back
 # $mms_compare_physically : to compare both byte-for-byte
-# 2) set $mms_table_to_use to a number N: table will be mysqltest.tN
+# 2) set $mms_tname to a string and set $mms_table_to_use to a number: tables
+# will be mysqltest.$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.
 # 3) set $mms_purpose to say what this copy is for (influences the naming
 # of the spare directory).
 
 if ($mms_copy)
 {
-  --echo * copied t$mms_table_to_use for $mms_purpose
-  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
-  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
-  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.frm $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.frm;
+  --echo * copied $mms_tname$mms_table_to_use for $mms_purpose
+  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
+  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
+  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.frm $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.frm;
 }
 
 if ($mms_reverse_copy)
 {
   # do not call this without flushing target table first!
-  --echo * copied t$mms_table_to_use back for $mms_purpose
+  --echo * copied $mms_tname$mms_table_to_use back for $mms_purpose
  -- error 0,1
-  remove_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
-  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
+  remove_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
+  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
   -- error 0,1
-  remove_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
-  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
+  remove_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
+  copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
 }
 
 if ($mms_compare_physically)
@@ -41,8 +42,8 @@ if ($mms_compare_physically)
   # So, do this only when testing REDO phase.
   # If UNDO phase, we nevertheless compare checksums
   # (see maria_verify_recovery.inc).
-  --echo * compared t$mms_table_to_use to old version
-  diff_files $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
+  --echo * compared $mms_tname$mms_table_to_use to old version
+  diff_files $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAD;
 # index file not yet recovered
-#  diff_files $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/t$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
+#  diff_files $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose/$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use.MAI;
 }

mysql-test/include/maria_make_snapshot_for_comparison.inc

 # Maria helper script
 # Copies clean tables' data and index file to other directory
-# Tables are t1...t[$mms_tables]
+# Tables are $mms_tname1...$mms_tname[$mms_tables]
 # They are later used as a reference to see if recovery works.
 
 # API:
-# set $mms_tables to N, the script will cover tables mysqltest.t1,...tN
+# set $mms_tname to a string, and $mms_tables to a number N, the script will
+# cover tables mysqltest.$mms_tname1,...$mms_tnameN
 
 connection admin;
 
@@ -22,7 +23,7 @@ eval create database mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose;
 while ($mms_table_to_use)
 {
   # to serve as a reference, table must be in a clean state
-  eval flush table t$mms_table_to_use;
+  eval flush table $mms_tname$mms_table_to_use;
   -- source include/maria_make_snapshot.inc
   dec $mms_table_to_use;
 }

mysql-test/include/maria_make_snapshot_for_feeding_recovery.inc

 # Maria helper script
 # Copies tables' data and index file to other directory, and control file.
-# Tables are t1...t[$mms_tables].
+# Tables are $mms_tname1...$mms_tname[$mms_tables].
 # Later, mysqld is shutdown, and that snapshot is put back into the
 # datadir, control file too ("flashing recovery's brain"), and recovery is let
 # to run on it (see maria_verify_recovery.inc).
 
 # API:
-# set $mms_tables to N, the script will cover tables mysqltest.t1,...tN
+# set $mms_tname to a string, and $mms_tables to a number N, the script will
+# cover tables mysqltest.$mms_tname1,...$mms_tnameN
+
 
 connection admin;
 

mysql-test/include/maria_verify_recovery.inc

@@ -2,7 +2,8 @@
 # Runs recovery, compare with expected table data.
 
 # API:
-# 1) set $mms_tables to N, the script will cover tables mysqltest.t1,...tN
+# 1) set $mms_tname to a string, and $mms_tables to a number N, the script
+# will cover tables mysqltest.$mms_tname1,...$mms_tnameN
 # 2) set $mvr_debug_option to the crash way
 # 3) set $mvr_crash_statement to the statement which will trigger a crash
 # 4) set $mvr_restore_old_snapshot to 1 if you want recovery to run on
@@ -77,10 +78,10 @@ let $mms_purpose=comparison;
 let $mms_compare_physically=$mms_compare_physically_save;
 while ($mms_table_to_use)
 {
-  eval check table t$mms_table_to_use extended;
+  eval check table $mms_tname$mms_table_to_use extended;
   --echo * testing that checksum after recovery is as expected
-  let $new_checksum=`CHECKSUM TABLE t$mms_table_to_use`;
-  let $old_checksum=`CHECKSUM TABLE mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose.t$mms_table_to_use`;
+  let $new_checksum=`CHECKSUM TABLE $mms_tname$mms_table_to_use`;
+  let $old_checksum=`CHECKSUM TABLE mysqltest_for_$mms_purpose.$mms_tname$mms_table_to_use`;
   # the $ text variables above are of the form "db.tablename\tchecksum",
   # as db differs, we use substring().
   --disable_query_log

mysql-test/lib/mtr_report.pl

@@ -405,7 +405,12 @@ sub mtr_report_stats ($) {
                 # maria-recovery.test has warning about missing log file
                 /File '.*maria_log.000.*' not found \(Errcode: 2\)/ or
                 # and about marked-corrupted table
-                /Table '.\/mysqltest\/t1' is crashed, skipping it. Please repair it with maria_chk -r/
+                /Table '.\/mysqltest\/t_corrupted1' is crashed, skipping it. Please repair it with maria_chk -r/ or
+                # maria-recover.test corrupts tables on purpose
+                /Checking table:   '.\/mysqltest\/t_corrupted2'/ or
+                /Recovering table: '.\/mysqltest\/t_corrupted2'/ or
+                /Table '.\/mysqltest\/t_corrupted2' is marked as crashed and should be repaired/ or
+                /Incorrect key file for table '.\/mysqltest\/t_corrupted2.MAI'; try to repair it/
 	       )
             {
               next;                       # Skip these lines

mysql-test/r/maria-preload.result

 drop table if exists t1, t2;
+create temporary table initial
+select variable_name,variable_value from
+information_schema.global_status where variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%";
 create table t1 (
 a int not null auto_increment,
 b char(16) not null,
@@ -46,24 +49,24 @@ count(*)
 20672
 flush tables;
 flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211388
-Maria_pagecache_reads	115
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	211644
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	3
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
 count(*)
 4181
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211414
-Maria_pagecache_reads	122
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	211926
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	11
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
 count(*)
 4181
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211440
-Maria_pagecache_reads	122
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	212208
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	12
 flush tables;
 flush status;
 select @@preload_buffer_size;
@@ -72,23 +75,23 @@ select @@preload_buffer_size;
 load index into cache t1;
 Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
 test.t1	preload_keys	status	OK
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211511
-Maria_pagecache_reads	193
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	212535
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	84
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
 count(*)
 4181
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211537
-Maria_pagecache_reads	193
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	212817
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	85
 flush tables;
 flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211537
-Maria_pagecache_reads	193
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	213073
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	86
 set session preload_buffer_size=256*1024;
 select @@preload_buffer_size;
 @@preload_buffer_size
@@ -96,23 +99,23 @@ select @@preload_buffer_size;
 load index into cache t1 ignore leaves;
 Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
 test.t1	preload_keys	status	OK
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211608
-Maria_pagecache_reads	264
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	213400
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	158
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
 count(*)
 4181
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211634
-Maria_pagecache_reads	270
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	213682
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	165
 flush tables;
 flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211634
-Maria_pagecache_reads	270
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	213938
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	166
 set session preload_buffer_size=1*1024;
 select @@preload_buffer_size;
 @@preload_buffer_size
@@ -121,52 +124,53 @@ load index into cache t1, t2 key (primary,b) ignore leaves;
 Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
 test.t1	preload_keys	status	OK
 test.t2	preload_keys	status	OK
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211748
-Maria_pagecache_reads	384
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	214308
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	281
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
 count(*)
 4181
 select count(*) from t2 where b = 'test1';
 count(*)
 2584
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211788
-Maria_pagecache_reads	387
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	214604
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	285
 flush tables;
 flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211788
-Maria_pagecache_reads	387
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	214860
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	286
 load index into cache t3, t2 key (primary,b) ;
 Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
 test.t3	preload_keys	Error	Table 'test.t3' doesn't exist
 test.t3	preload_keys	error	Corrupt
 test.t2	preload_keys	status	OK
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211831
-Maria_pagecache_reads	430
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	215159
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	330
 flush tables;
 flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211831
-Maria_pagecache_reads	430
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	215415
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	331
 load index into cache t3 key (b), t2 key (c) ;
 Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
 test.t3	preload_keys	Error	Table 'test.t3' doesn't exist
 test.t3	preload_keys	error	Corrupt
 test.t2	preload_keys	Error	Key 'c' doesn't exist in table 't2'
 test.t2	preload_keys	status	Operation failed
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-Variable_name	Value
-Maria_pagecache_read_requests	211831
-Maria_pagecache_reads	430
+select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+variable_name	g.variable_value-i.variable_value
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READ_REQUESTS	215671
+MARIA_PAGECACHE_READS	332
 drop table t1, t2;
+drop temporary table initial;
 show status like "key_read%";
 Variable_name	Value
 Key_read_requests	0

mysql-test/r/maria-purge.result

@@ -37,13 +37,13 @@ set global maria_log_file_size=16777216;
 set global maria_checkpoint_interval=30;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000002	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000002	in use
 insert into t2 select * from t1;
 insert into t1 select * from t2;
 set global maria_checkpoint_interval=30;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000004	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000004	in use
 set global maria_log_file_size=16777216;
 select @@global.maria_log_file_size;
 @@global.maria_log_file_size
@@ -51,7 +51,7 @@ select @@global.maria_log_file_size;
 set global maria_checkpoint_interval=30;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000004	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000004	in use
 set global maria_log_file_size=8388608;
 select @@global.maria_log_file_size;
 @@global.maria_log_file_size
@@ -61,32 +61,32 @@ insert into t1 select * from t2;
 set global maria_checkpoint_interval=30;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000004	free
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000005	free
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000006	free
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000007	free
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000008	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000004	free
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000005	free
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000006	free
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000007	free
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000008	in use
 flush logs;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000008	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000008	in use
 set global maria_log_file_size=16777216;
 set global maria_log_purge_type=external;
 insert into t1 select * from t2;
 set global maria_checkpoint_interval=30;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000008	free
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000009	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000008	free
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000009	in use
 flush logs;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000008	free
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000009	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000008	free
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000009	in use
 set global maria_log_purge_type=immediate;
 insert into t1 select * from t2;
 set global maria_checkpoint_interval=30;
 SHOW ENGINE maria logs;
 Type	Name	Status
-maria	master-data/maria_log.00000011	in use
+MARIA	master-data/maria_log.00000011	in use
 drop table t1, t2;

mysql-test/r/maria-recover.result

+select @@global.maria_recover;
+@@global.maria_recover
+BACKUP
+set global maria_recover=off;
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+@@global.maria_recover
+OFF
+set global maria_recover=default;
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+@@global.maria_recover
+OFF
+set global maria_recover=normal;
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+@@global.maria_recover
+NORMAL
+drop database if exists mysqltest;
+create database mysqltest;
+use mysqltest;
+create table t1 (a varchar(1000), index(a)) engine=maria;
+insert into t1 values("ThursdayMorningsMarket");
+flush table t1;
+insert into t1 select concat(a,'b') from t1 limit 1;
+select * from t_corrupted2;
+a
+ThursdayMorningsMarket
+Warnings:
+Error	145	Table './mysqltest/t_corrupted2' is marked as crashed and should be repaired
+Error	1194	Table 't_corrupted2' is marked as crashed and should be repaired
+Error	1034	1 client is using or hasn't closed the table properly
+Error	126	Incorrect key file for table './mysqltest/t_corrupted2.MAI'; try to repair it
+Error	1034	Wrong base information on indexpage at page: 1
+select * from t_corrupted2;
+a
+ThursdayMorningsMarket
+drop database mysqltest;

mysql-test/r/maria-recovery.result

@@ -362,24 +362,24 @@ Table	Non_unique	Key_name	Seq_in_index	Column_name	Collation	Cardinality	Sub_par
 t1	1	a	1	a	A	1	NULL	NULL	YES	BTREE	
 drop table t1;
 * TEST of recovery when OPTIMIZE has replaced the index file and crash
-create table t1 (a varchar(100), key(a)) engine=maria;
-insert into t1 select (rand()) from t2;
-flush table t1;
-* copied t1 for comparison
+create table t_corrupted1 (a varchar(100), key(a)) engine=maria;
+insert into t_corrupted1 select (rand()) from t2;
+flush table t_corrupted1;
+* copied t_corrupted1 for comparison
 SET SESSION debug="+d,maria_flush_whole_log,maria_flush_whole_page_cache,maria_crash_sort_index";
 * crashing mysqld intentionally
-optimize table t1;
+optimize table t_corrupted1;
 ERROR HY000: Lost connection to MySQL server during query
 * recovery happens
-check table t1 extended;
+check table t_corrupted1 extended;
 Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
-mysqltest.t1	check	warning	Table is marked as crashed and last repair failed
-mysqltest.t1	check	status	OK
+mysqltest.t_corrupted1	check	warning	Table is marked as crashed and last repair failed
+mysqltest.t_corrupted1	check	status	OK
 * testing that checksum after recovery is as expected
 Checksum-check
 ok
 use mysqltest;
-drop table t1, t2;
+drop table t_corrupted1, t2;
 drop database mysqltest_for_feeding_recovery;
 drop database mysqltest_for_comparison;
 drop database mysqltest;

mysql-test/r/maria.result

@@ -2121,6 +2121,7 @@ show variables like 'maria%';
 Variable_name	Value
 maria_block_size	8192
 maria_checkpoint_interval	30
+maria_force_start_after_recovery_failures	0
 maria_log_file_size	4294959104
 maria_log_purge_type	immediate
 maria_max_sort_file_size	9223372036854775807
@@ -2128,6 +2129,7 @@ maria_page_checksum	OFF
 maria_pagecache_age_threshold	300
 maria_pagecache_buffer_size	8388600
 maria_pagecache_division_limit	100
+maria_recover	OFF
 maria_repair_threads	1
 maria_sort_buffer_size	8388608
 maria_stats_method	nulls_unequal

mysql-test/t/disabled.def

@@ -19,4 +19,4 @@ ctype_create         : Bug#32965 main.ctype_create fails
 status               : Bug#32966 main.status fails
 ps_ddl               : Bug#12093 2007-12-14 pending WL#4165 / WL#4166
 csv_alter_table      : Bug#33696 2008-01-21 pcrews no .result file - bug allows NULL columns in CSV tables
-maria-preload        : Bug#34911 unrepeatable output of SHOW STATUS
+maria-preload        : Bug#35107 crashes

mysql-test/t/maria-preload.test

@@ -8,6 +8,11 @@
 drop table if exists t1, t2;
 --enable_warnings
 
+# Work around BUG#34911 "FLUSH STATUS doesn't flush what it should":
+# compute differences in status variables before and after relevant queries
+create temporary table initial
+select variable_name,variable_value from
+information_schema.global_status where variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%";
 
 # we don't use block-format because we want page cache stats
 # about indices and not data pages.
@@ -59,50 +64,50 @@ select count(*) from t1;
 select count(*) from t2;
 
 flush tables; flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-
+let $show_stat=select g.variable_name,g.variable_value-i.variable_value from information_schema.global_status as g,initial as i where g.variable_name like "Maria_pagecache_read%" and g.variable_name=i.variable_name order by g.variable_name desc;
+eval $show_stat;
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 
 flush tables; flush status;
 select @@preload_buffer_size;
 load index into cache t1;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 
 flush tables; flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 set session preload_buffer_size=256*1024;
 select @@preload_buffer_size;
 load index into cache t1 ignore leaves;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 
 flush tables; flush status; 
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 set session preload_buffer_size=1*1024;
 select @@preload_buffer_size;
 load index into cache t1, t2 key (primary,b) ignore leaves;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 select count(*) from t1 where b = 'test1';
 select count(*) from t2 where b = 'test1';
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 
 flush tables; flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 load index into cache t3, t2 key (primary,b) ;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
-
+eval $show_stat;
 flush tables; flush status;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 load index into cache t3 key (b), t2 key (c) ;
-show status like "maria_pagecache_read%";
+eval $show_stat;
 
 drop table t1, t2;
+drop temporary table initial;
 
 # check that Maria didn't use key cache
 show status like "key_read%";

mysql-test/t/maria-recover-master.opt

+--maria-recover=backup --maria-log-dir-path=../tmp

mysql-test/t/maria-recover.test

+# Test of the --maria-recover option.
+
+--source include/have_maria.inc
+
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+set global maria_recover=off;
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+set global maria_recover=default;
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+set global maria_recover=normal;
+select @@global.maria_recover;
+
+--disable_warnings
+drop database if exists mysqltest;
+--enable_warnings
+create database mysqltest;
+
+use mysqltest;
+
+create table t1 (a varchar(1000), index(a)) engine=maria;
+insert into t1 values("ThursdayMorningsMarket");
+
+flush table t1; # put index page on disk
+insert into t1 select concat(a,'b') from t1 limit 1;
+# now t1 has its open_count>0 and so will t2_corrupted.
+# It is not named t2 because the corruption messages which will be put
+# in the error log need to be detected in mtr_process.pl, and we want
+# a specific name to do specific detection (don't want to ignore
+# any corruption messages of other tests using "t2" as table).
+
+copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t1.frm $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t_corrupted2.frm;
+copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t1.MAD $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t_corrupted2.MAD;
+copy_file $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t1.MAI $MYSQLTEST_VARDIR/master-data/mysqltest/t_corrupted2.MAI;
+
+# Ruin the index file.
+# If maria-block-size is smaller than the default, the corruption
+# messages will differ.
+perl;
+    use strict;
+    use warnings;
+    my $fname= "$ENV{'MYSQLTEST_VARDIR'}/master-data/mysqltest/t_corrupted2.MAI";
+    open(FILE, "+<", $fname) or die;
+    my $whatever= ("\xAB" x 100);
+    sysseek (FILE, 8192, 0) or die;
+    syswrite (FILE, $whatever) or die;
+    close FILE;
+EOF
+
+select * from t_corrupted2; # should show corruption and repair messages
+select * from t_corrupted2; # should show just rows
+
+drop database mysqltest;

mysql-test/t/maria-recovery-big.test

@@ -15,6 +15,7 @@ set global maria_log_file_size=4294967295;
 drop database if exists mysqltest;
 --enable_warnings
 create database mysqltest;
+let $mms_tname=t;
 
 # Include scripts can perform SQL. For it to not influence the main test
 # they use a separate connection. This way if they use a DDL it would

mysql-test/t/maria-recovery-bitmap.test

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@
 drop database if exists mysqltest;
 --enable_warnings
 create database mysqltest;
+let $mms_tname=t;
 
 # Include scripts can perform SQL. For it to not influence the main test
 # they use a separate connection. This way if they use a DDL it would

mysql-test/t/maria-recovery-rtree-ft.test

@@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ let $MARIA_LOG=.;
 drop database if exists mysqltest;
 --enable_warnings
 create database mysqltest;
+let $mms_tname=t;
 
 # Include scripts can perform SQL. For it to not influence the main test
 # they use a separate connection. This way if they use a DDL it would

mysql-test/t/maria-recovery.test

@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ let $MARIA_LOG=../tmp;
 drop database if exists mysqltest;
 --enable_warnings
 create database mysqltest;
+let $mms_tname=t;
 
 # Include scripts can perform SQL. For it to not influence the main test
 # they use a separate connection. This way if they use a DDL it would
@@ -297,19 +298,25 @@ show keys from t1; # should be enabled
 drop table t1;
 
 --echo * TEST of recovery when OPTIMIZE has replaced the index file and crash
-create table t1 (a varchar(100), key(a)) engine=maria;
+create table t_corrupted1 (a varchar(100), key(a)) engine=maria;
+# we use a special name because this test portion will generate
+# corruption warnings, which we tell mtr_report.pl to ignore by
+# putting the message in mtr_report.pl, but we don't want to it ignore
+# corruption messages of other tests, hence the special name
+# 't_corrupted' and not just 't'.
+let $mms_tname=t_corrupted;
 let $mvr_restore_old_snapshot=0;
 let $mms_compare_physically=0;
-let $mvr_crash_statement= optimize table t1;
+let $mvr_crash_statement= optimize table t_corrupted1;
 let $mvr_debug_option="+d,maria_flush_whole_log,maria_flush_whole_page_cache,maria_crash_sort_index";
-insert into t1 select (rand()) from t2;
+insert into t_corrupted1 select (rand()) from t2;
 -- source include/maria_make_snapshot_for_comparison.inc
 # Recovery will not fix the table, but we expect to see it marked
 # "crashed on repair".
 # Because crash is mild, the table is actually not corrupted, so the
 # "check table extended" done below fixes the table.
 -- source include/maria_verify_recovery.inc
-drop table t1, t2;
+drop table t_corrupted1, t2;
 
 # clean up everything
 let $mms_purpose=feeding_recovery;

storage/maria/ma_checkpoint.c

@@ -245,7 +245,8 @@ static int really_execute_checkpoint(void)
       that log was flushed before we write to the control file).
     */
     if (unlikely(ma_control_file_write_and_force(lsn, last_logno,
-                                                 max_trid_in_control_file)))
+                                                 max_trid_in_control_file,
+                                                 recovery_failures)))
     {
       translog_unlock();
       goto err;

storage/maria/ma_control_file.c

@@ -39,6 +39,8 @@ Start of changeable part:
   - Checksum of changeable part
   - LSN of last checkpoint
   - Number of last log file
+  - Max trid in control file (since Maria 1.5 May 2008)
+  - Number of consecutive recovery failures (since Maria 1.5 May 2008)
 .....  Here we can add new variables without changing format
 
 The idea is that one can add new variables to the control file and still
@@ -80,7 +82,9 @@ one should increment the control file version number.
 #define CF_FILENO_SIZE 4
 #define CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET (CF_FILENO_OFFSET + CF_FILENO_SIZE)
 #define CF_MAX_TRID_SIZE TRANSID_SIZE
-#define CF_CHANGEABLE_TOTAL_SIZE (CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET + CF_MAX_TRID_SIZE)
+#define CF_RECOV_FAIL_OFFSET (CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET + CF_MAX_TRID_SIZE)
+#define CF_RECOV_FAIL_SIZE 1
+#define CF_CHANGEABLE_TOTAL_SIZE (CF_RECOV_FAIL_OFFSET + CF_RECOV_FAIL_SIZE)
 
 /*
   The following values should not be changed, except when changing version
@@ -108,6 +112,12 @@ uint32 last_logno=          FILENO_IMPOSSIBLE;
 */
 TrID   max_trid_in_control_file= 0;
 
+/**
+  Number of consecutive log or recovery failures. Reset to 0 after recovery's
+  success.
+*/
+uint8 recovery_failures= 0;
+
 /**
    @brief If log's lock should be asserted when writing to control file.
 
@@ -188,7 +198,7 @@ static CONTROL_FILE_ERROR create_control_file(const char *name,
 
   /* init the file with these "undefined" values */
   DBUG_RETURN(ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN_IMPOSSIBLE,
-                                              FILENO_IMPOSSIBLE, 0));
+                                              FILENO_IMPOSSIBLE, 0, 0));
 }
 
 
@@ -420,6 +430,9 @@ CONTROL_FILE_ERROR ma_control_file_open(my_bool create_if_missing,
   if (new_cf_changeable_size >= (CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET + CF_MAX_TRID_SIZE))
     max_trid_in_control_file=
       transid_korr(buffer + new_cf_create_time_size + CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET);
+  if (new_cf_changeable_size >= (CF_RECOV_FAIL_OFFSET + CF_RECOV_FAIL_SIZE))
+    recovery_failures=
+      (buffer + new_cf_create_time_size + CF_RECOV_FAIL_OFFSET)[0];
 
 ok:
   DBUG_RETURN(0);
@@ -436,19 +449,21 @@ CONTROL_FILE_ERROR ma_control_file_open(my_bool create_if_missing,
 
 /*
   Write information durably to the control file; stores this information into
-  the last_checkpoint_lsn, last_logno, max_trid_in_control_file global
-  variables.
+  the last_checkpoint_lsn, last_logno, max_trid_in_control_file,
+  recovery_failures global variables.
   Called when we have created a new log (after syncing this log's creation),
-  when we have written a checkpoint (after syncing this log record), and at
-  shutdown (for storing trid in case logs are soon removed by user).
+  when we have written a checkpoint (after syncing this log record), at
+  shutdown (for storing trid in case logs are soon removed by user), and
+  before and after recovery (to store recovery_failures).
   Variables last_checkpoint_lsn and last_logno must be protected by caller
   using log's lock, unless this function is called at startup.
 
   SYNOPSIS
     ma_control_file_write_and_force()
-    checkpoint_lsn       LSN of last checkpoint
-    logno                last log file number
-    trid                 maximum transaction longid.
+    last_checkpoint_lsn_arg LSN of last checkpoint
+    last_logno_arg          last log file number
+    max_trid_arg            maximum transaction longid
+    recovery_failures_arg   consecutive recovery failures
 
   NOTE
     We always want to do one single my_pwrite() here to be as atomic as
@@ -459,17 +474,26 @@ CONTROL_FILE_ERROR ma_control_file_open(my_bool create_if_missing,
     1 - Error
 */
 
-int ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno,
-                                    TrID trid)
+int ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN last_checkpoint_lsn_arg,
+                                    uint32 last_logno_arg,
+                                    TrID max_trid_arg,
+                                    uint8 recovery_failures_arg)
 {
   uchar buffer[CF_MAX_SIZE];
   uint32 sum;
+  my_bool no_need_sync;
   DBUG_ENTER("ma_control_file_write_and_force");
 
-  if ((last_checkpoint_lsn == checkpoint_lsn) &&
-      (last_logno == logno) &&
-      (max_trid_in_control_file == trid))
-    DBUG_RETURN(0); /* no need to write */
+  /*
+    We don't need to sync if this is just an increase of
+    recovery_failures: it's even good if that counter is not increased on disk
+    in case of power or hardware failure (less false positives when removing
+    logs).
+  */
+  no_need_sync= ((last_checkpoint_lsn == last_checkpoint_lsn_arg) &&
+                 (last_logno == last_logno_arg) &&
+                 (max_trid_in_control_file == max_trid_arg) &&
+                 (recovery_failures_arg > 0));
 
   if (control_file_fd < 0)
     DBUG_RETURN(1);
@@ -479,9 +503,10 @@ int ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno,
     translog_lock_handler_assert_owner();
 #endif
 
-  lsn_store(buffer + CF_LSN_OFFSET, checkpoint_lsn);
-  int4store(buffer + CF_FILENO_OFFSET, logno);
-  transid_store(buffer + CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET, trid);
+  lsn_store(buffer + CF_LSN_OFFSET, last_checkpoint_lsn_arg);
+  int4store(buffer + CF_FILENO_OFFSET, last_logno_arg);
+  transid_store(buffer + CF_MAX_TRID_OFFSET, max_trid_arg);
+  (buffer + CF_RECOV_FAIL_OFFSET)[0]= recovery_failures_arg;
 
   if (cf_changeable_size > CF_CHANGEABLE_TOTAL_SIZE)
   {
@@ -514,12 +539,13 @@ int ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno,
 
   if (my_pwrite(control_file_fd, buffer, cf_changeable_size,
                 cf_create_time_size, MYF(MY_FNABP |  MY_WME)) ||
-      my_sync(control_file_fd, MYF(MY_WME)))
+      (!no_need_sync && my_sync(control_file_fd, MYF(MY_WME))))
     DBUG_RETURN(1);
 
-  last_checkpoint_lsn= checkpoint_lsn;
-  last_logno= logno;
-  max_trid_in_control_file= trid;
+  last_checkpoint_lsn= last_checkpoint_lsn_arg;
+  last_logno= last_logno_arg;
+  max_trid_in_control_file= max_trid_arg;
+  recovery_failures= recovery_failures_arg;
 
   cf_changeable_size= CF_CHANGEABLE_TOTAL_SIZE; /* no more warning */
   DBUG_RETURN(0);
@@ -558,7 +584,7 @@ int ma_control_file_end(void)
   */
   last_checkpoint_lsn= LSN_IMPOSSIBLE;
   last_logno= FILENO_IMPOSSIBLE;
-  max_trid_in_control_file= 0;
+  max_trid_in_control_file= recovery_failures= 0;
 
   DBUG_RETURN(close_error);
 }

storage/maria/ma_control_file.h

@@ -44,6 +44,8 @@ extern uint32 last_logno;
 
 extern TrID max_trid_in_control_file;
 
+extern uint8 recovery_failures;
+
 extern my_bool maria_multi_threaded, maria_in_recovery;
 
 typedef enum enum_control_file_error {
@@ -63,7 +65,9 @@ typedef enum enum_control_file_error {
 C_MODE_START
 CONTROL_FILE_ERROR ma_control_file_open(my_bool create_if_missing,
                                         my_bool print_error);
-int ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno, TrID trid);
+int ma_control_file_write_and_force(LSN last_checkpoint_lsn_arg,
+                                    uint32 last_logno_arg, TrID max_trid_arg,
+                                    uint8 recovery_failures_arg);
 int ma_control_file_end(void);
 my_bool ma_control_file_inited(void);
 C_MODE_END

storage/maria/ma_init.c

@@ -86,7 +86,7 @@ void maria_end(void)
         from the log, as it cannot process REDOs).
       */
       (void)ma_control_file_write_and_force(last_checkpoint_lsn, last_logno,
-                                            trid);
+                                            trid, recovery_failures);
     }
     trnman_destroy();
     if (translog_status == TRANSLOG_OK)

storage/maria/ma_locking.c

@@ -381,7 +381,7 @@ int _ma_test_if_changed(register MARIA_HA *info)
   tells us if the MARIA file wasn't properly closed. (This is true if
   my_disable_locking is set).
 
-  open_count is not maintained on disk for transactional or temporary tables.
+  open_count is not maintained on disk for temporary tables.
 */
 
 int _ma_mark_file_changed(MARIA_HA *info)
@@ -400,11 +400,16 @@ int _ma_mark_file_changed(MARIA_HA *info)
       share->state.open_count++;
     }
     /*
-      temp tables don't need an open_count as they are removed on crash;
-      transactional tables are fixed by log-based recovery, so don't need an
-      open_count either (and we thus avoid the disk write below).
+      Temp tables don't need an open_count as they are removed on crash.
+      In theory transactional tables are fixed by log-based recovery, so don't
+      need an open_count either, but if recovery has failed and logs have been
+      removed (by maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures), we still need to
+      detect dubious tables.
+      If we didn't maintain open_count on disk for a table, after a crash
+      we wouldn't know if it was closed at crash time (thus does not need a
+      check) or not. So we would have to check all tables: overkill.
     */
-    if (!(share->temporary | share->base.born_transactional))
+    if (!share->temporary)
     {
       mi_int2store(buff,share->state.open_count);
       buff[2]=1;				/* Mark that it's changed */
@@ -471,7 +476,7 @@ int _ma_decrement_open_count(MARIA_HA *info)
     {
       share->state.open_count--;
       share->changed= 1;                        /* We have to update state */
-      if (!(share->temporary | share->base.born_transactional))
+      if (!share->temporary)
       {
         mi_int2store(buff,share->state.open_count);
         write_error= (int) my_pwrite(share->kfile.file, buff, sizeof(buff),

storage/maria/ma_loghandler.h

@@ -317,6 +317,10 @@ extern void translog_deassign_id_from_share(struct st_maria_share *share);
 extern void
 translog_assign_id_to_share_from_recovery(struct st_maria_share *share,
                                           uint16 id);
+extern my_bool translog_walk_filenames(const char *directory,
+                                       my_bool (*callback)(const char *,
+                                                           const char *));
+
 enum enum_translog_status
 {
   TRANSLOG_UNINITED, /* no initialization done or error during initialization */

storage/maria/ma_recovery.c

@@ -191,12 +191,12 @@ static void print_preamble()
      @retval !=0    Error
 */
 
-int maria_recover(void)
+int maria_recovery_from_log(void)
 {
   int res= 1;
   FILE *trace_file;
   uint warnings_count;
-  DBUG_ENTER("maria_recover");
+  DBUG_ENTER("maria_recovery_from_log");
 
   DBUG_ASSERT(!maria_in_recovery);
   maria_in_recovery= TRUE;
@@ -462,7 +462,12 @@ int maria_apply_log(LSN from_lsn, enum maria_apply_log_way apply,
                "Maria recovery failed. Please run maria_chk -r on all maria "
                "tables and delete all maria_log.######## files", MYF(0));
   procent_printed= 0;
-  /* we don't cleanly close tables if we hit some error (may corrupt them) */
+  /*
+    We don't cleanly close tables if we hit some error (may corrupt them by
+    flushing some wrong blocks made from wrong REDOs). It also leaves their
+    open_count>0, which ensures that --maria-recover, if used, will try to
+    repair them.
+  */
   DBUG_RETURN(error);
 }
 
@@ -1224,6 +1229,12 @@ static int new_table(uint16 sid, const char *name, LSN lsn_of_file_id)
            " maria_chk -r", share->open_file_name);
     error= -1; /* not fatal, try with other tables */
     goto end;
+    /*
+      Note that if a first recovery fails to apply a REDO, it marks the table
+      corrupted and stops the entire recovery. A second recovery will find the
+      table is marked corrupted and skip it (and thus possibly handle other
+      tables).
+    */
   }
   /* don't log any records for this work */
   _ma_tmp_disable_logging_for_table(info, FALSE);

storage/maria/ma_recovery.h

@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@
 C_MODE_START
 enum maria_apply_log_way
 { MARIA_LOG_APPLY, MARIA_LOG_DISPLAY_HEADER, MARIA_LOG_CHECK };
-int maria_recover(void);
+int maria_recovery_from_log(void);
 int maria_apply_log(LSN lsn, enum maria_apply_log_way apply,
                     FILE *trace_file,
                     my_bool execute_undo_phase, my_bool skip_DDLs,

storage/maria/ma_test_force_start.pl

+#!/usr/bin/env perl
+
+
+use strict;
+use warnings;
+
+my $usage= <<EOF;
+This program tests that the options
+--maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures --maria-recover work as
+expected.
+It has to be run from directory mysql-test, and works with non-debug
+and debug binaries.
+Pass it option -d or -i (to test corruption of data or index file).
+EOF
+
+# -d currently exhibits BUG#36578
+# "Maria: maria-recover may fail to autorepair a table"
+
+die($usage) if (@ARGV == 0);
+
+my $corrupt_index;
+
+if ($ARGV[0] eq '-d')
+  {
+    $corrupt_index= 0;
+  }
+elsif ($ARGV[0] eq '-i')
+  {
+    $corrupt_index= 1;
+  }
+else
+  {
+    die($usage);
+  }
+
+my $force_after= 3;
+my $corrupt_file= $corrupt_index ? "MAI" : "MAD";
+my $corrupt_message= 
+  "\\[ERROR\\] mysqld: Table '.\/test\/t1' is marked as crashed and should be repaired";
+
+my $sql_name= "./var/tmp/create_table.sql";
+my $error_log_name= "./var/log/master.err";
+my @cmd_output;
+my $whatever; # garbage data
+my $base_server_cmd= "perl mysql-test-run.pl --mem --mysqld=--maria-force-start-after-recovery-failures=$force_after maria-recover";
+my $server_cmd;
+my $client_cmd= "../client/mysql -u root -S var/tmp/master.sock test < $sql_name";
+my $server_pid_name="./var/run/master.pid";
+my $server_pid;
+my $i; # count of server restarts
+sub kill_server;
+
+print "starting mysqld\n";
+$server_cmd= $base_server_cmd . " --start-and-exit 2>&1";
+@cmd_output=`$server_cmd`;
+die if $?;
+
+open(FILE, ">", $sql_name) or die;
+
+# To exhibit BUG#36578 with -d, we don't create an index if -d. This is
+# because the presence of an index will cause repair-by-sort to be used,
+# where sort_get_next_record() is only called inside
+#_ma_create_index_by_sort(), so the latter function fails and in this
+# case retry_repair is set, so bug does not happen. Whereas without
+# an index, repair-with-key-cache is called, which calls
+# sort_get_next_record() whose failure itself does not cause a retry.
+
+print FILE "create table t1 (a varchar(1000)".
+  ($corrupt_index ? ", index(a)" : "") .") engine=maria;\n";
+print FILE <<EOF;
+insert into t1 values("ThursdayMorningsMarket");
+# If Recovery executes REDO_INDEX_NEW_PAGE it will overwrite our
+# intentional corruption; we make Recovery skip this record by bumping
+# create_rename_lsn using OPTIMIZE TABLE. This also makes sure to put
+# the pages on disk, so that we can corrupt them.
+optimize table t1;
+# mark table open, so that --maria-recover repairs it
+insert into t1 select concat(a,'b') from t1 limit 1;
+EOF
+close FILE;
+
+print "creating table\n";
+`$client_cmd`;
+die if $?;
+
+print "killing mysqld hard\n";
+kill_server(9);
+
+print "ruining " .
+  ($corrupt_index ? "first page of keys" : "bitmap page") .
+  " in table to test maria-recover\n";
+open(FILE, "+<", "./var/master-data/test/t1.$corrupt_file") or die;
+$whatever= ("\xAB" x 100);
+sysseek (FILE, $corrupt_index ? 8192 : (8192-100-100), 0) or die;
+syswrite (FILE, $whatever) or die;
+close FILE;
+
+print "ruining log to make recovery fail; mysqld should fail the $force_after first restarts\n";
+open(FILE, "+<", "./var/tmp/maria_log.00000001") or die;
+$whatever= ("\xAB" x 8192);
+sysseek (FILE, 99, 0) or die;
+syswrite (FILE, $whatever) or die;
+close FILE;
+
+$server_cmd= $base_server_cmd . " --start-dirty 2>&1";
+for($i= 1; $i <= $force_after; $i= $i + 1)
+  {
+    print "mysqld restart number $i... ";
+    unlink($error_log_name) or die;
+    `$server_cmd`;
+    # mysqld should return 1 when can't read log
+    die unless (($? >> 8) == 1);
+    open(FILE, "<", $error_log_name) or die;
+    @cmd_output= <FILE>;
+    close FILE;
+    die unless grep(/\[ERROR\] mysqld: Maria engine: log initialization failed/, @cmd_output);
+    die unless grep(/\[ERROR\] Plugin 'MARIA' init function returned error./, @cmd_output);
+    print "failed - ok\n";
+  }
+
+print "mysqld restart number $i... ";
+unlink($error_log_name) or die;
+@cmd_output=`$server_cmd`;
+die if $?;
+open(FILE, "<", $error_log_name) or die;
+@cmd_output= <FILE>;
+close FILE;
+die unless grep(/\[Warning\] mysqld: Maria engine: removed all logs after [\d]+ consecutive failures of recovery from logs/, @cmd_output);
+die unless grep(/\[ERROR\] mysqld: File '..\/tmp\/maria_log.00000001' not found \(Errcode: 2\)/, @cmd_output);
+print "success - ok\n";
+
+open(FILE, ">", $sql_name) or die;
+print FILE <<EOF;
+set global maria_recover=normal;
+insert into t1 values('aaa');
+EOF
+close FILE;
+
+# verify corruption has not yet been noticed
+open(FILE, "<", $error_log_name) or die;
+@cmd_output= <FILE>;
+close FILE;
+die if grep(/$corrupt_message/, @cmd_output);
+
+print "inserting in table\n";
+`$client_cmd`;
+die if $?;
+print "table is usable - ok\n";
+
+open(FILE, "<", $error_log_name) or die;
+@cmd_output= <FILE>;
+close FILE;
+die unless grep(/$corrupt_message/, @cmd_output);
+die unless grep(/\[Warning\] Recovering table: '.\/test\/t1'/, @cmd_output);
+print "was corrupted and automatically repaired - ok\n";
+
+# remove our traces
+kill_server(15);
+
+print "TEST ALL OK\n";
+
+# kills mysqld with signal given in parameter
+sub kill_server
+  {
+    my ($sig)= @_;
+    my $wait_count= 0;
+    open(FILE, "<", $server_pid_name) or die;
+    @cmd_output= <FILE>;
+    close FILE;
+    $server_pid= $cmd_output[0];
+    die unless $server_pid > 0;
+    kill($sig, $server_pid) or die;
+    while (kill (0, $server_pid))
+      {
+        print "waiting for mysqld to die\n" if ($wait_count > 30);
+        $wait_count= $wait_count + 1;
+        select(undef, undef, undef, 0.1);
+      }
+  }

storage/maria/unittest/ma_control_file-t.c

@@ -45,6 +45,7 @@ char file_name[FN_REFLEN];
 LSN    expect_checkpoint_lsn;
 uint32 expect_logno;
 TrID   expect_max_trid;
+uint8  expect_recovery_failures;
 
 static int delete_file(myf my_flags);
 /*
@@ -55,10 +56,11 @@ static int close_file(void); /* wraps ma_control_file_end */
 /* wraps ma_control_file_open_or_create */
 static int open_file(void);
 /* wraps ma_control_file_write_and_force */
-static int write_file(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno, TrID trid);
+static int write_file(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno, TrID trid,
+                      uint8 rec_failures);
 
 /* Tests */
-static int test_one_log(void);
+static int test_one_log_and_recovery_failures(void);
 static int test_five_logs_and_max_trid(void);
 static int test_3_checkpoints_and_2_logs(void);
 static int test_binary_content(void);
@@ -135,7 +137,8 @@ int main(int argc,char *argv[])
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(0 == delete_file(0)); /* if fails, can't continue */
 
   diag("Tests of normal conditions");
-  ok(0 == test_one_log(), "test of creating one log");
+  ok(0 == test_one_log_and_recovery_failures(),
+     "test of creating one log and recording recovery failures");
   ok(0 == test_five_logs_and_max_trid(),
      "test of creating five logs and many transactions");
   ok(0 == test_3_checkpoints_and_2_logs(),
@@ -167,7 +170,7 @@ static int delete_file(myf my_flags)
   my_delete(file_name, my_flags);
   expect_checkpoint_lsn= LSN_IMPOSSIBLE;
   expect_logno= FILENO_IMPOSSIBLE;
-  expect_max_trid= 0;
+  expect_max_trid= expect_recovery_failures= 0;
 
   return 0;
 }
@@ -181,6 +184,7 @@ static int verify_module_values_match_expected(void)
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(last_logno == expect_logno);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(last_checkpoint_lsn == expect_checkpoint_lsn);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(max_trid_in_control_file == expect_max_trid);
+  RET_ERR_UNLESS(recovery_failures == expect_recovery_failures);
   return 0;
 }
 
@@ -215,21 +219,28 @@ static int open_file(void)
   return 0;
 }
 
-static int write_file(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno, TrID trid)
+static int write_file(LSN checkpoint_lsn, uint32 logno, TrID trid,
+                      uint8 rec_failures)
 {
-  RET_ERR_UNLESS(ma_control_file_write_and_force(checkpoint_lsn, logno, trid)
+  RET_ERR_UNLESS(ma_control_file_write_and_force(checkpoint_lsn, logno, trid,
+                                                 rec_failures)
                  == 0);
   /* Check that the module reports expected information */
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(verify_module_values_match_expected() == 0);
   return 0;
 }
 
-static int test_one_log(void)
+static int test_one_log_and_recovery_failures(void)
 {
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(open_file() == CONTROL_FILE_OK);
   expect_logno= 123;
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(last_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                            max_trid_in_control_file) == 0);
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            recovery_failures) == 0);
+  expect_recovery_failures= 158;
+  RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(last_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            expect_recovery_failures) == 0);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(close_file() == 0);
   return 0;
 }
@@ -245,7 +256,8 @@ static int test_five_logs_and_max_trid(void)
   {
     expect_logno*= 3;
     RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(last_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                              expect_max_trid) == 0);
+                              expect_max_trid,
+                              recovery_failures) == 0);
   }
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(close_file() == 0);
   return 0;
@@ -260,23 +272,28 @@ static int test_3_checkpoints_and_2_logs(void)
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(open_file() == CONTROL_FILE_OK);
   expect_checkpoint_lsn= MAKE_LSN(5, 10000);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(expect_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                            max_trid_in_control_file) == 0);
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            recovery_failures) == 0);
 
   expect_logno= 17;
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(expect_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                            max_trid_in_control_file) == 0);
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            recovery_failures) == 0);
 
   expect_checkpoint_lsn= MAKE_LSN(17, 20000);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(expect_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                            max_trid_in_control_file) == 0);
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            recovery_failures) == 0);
 
   expect_checkpoint_lsn= MAKE_LSN(17, 45000);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(expect_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                            max_trid_in_control_file) == 0);
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            recovery_failures) == 0);
 
   expect_logno= 19;
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(write_file(expect_checkpoint_lsn, expect_logno,
-                            max_trid_in_control_file) == 0);
+                            max_trid_in_control_file,
+                            recovery_failures) == 0);
   RET_ERR_UNLESS(close_file() == 0);
   return 0;
 }

storage/maria/unittest/ma_test_loghandler_multigroup-t.c

@@ -129,10 +129,10 @@ static my_bool read_and_check_content(TRANSLOG_HEADER_BUFFER *rec,
 }
 
 static const char *load_default_groups[]= {"ma_unit_loghandler", 0};
-#if defined(__WIN__)
-static const char *default_dbug_option= "d:t:i:O,\\ma_test_loghandler.trace";
-#else
-static const char *default_dbug_option= "d:t:i:o,/tmp/ma_test_loghandler.trace";
+#ifndef DBUG_OFF
+static const char *default_dbug_option=
+  IF_WIN("d:t:i:O,\\ma_test_loghandler.trace",
+         "d:t:i:o,/tmp/ma_test_loghandler.trace");
 #endif
 static const char *opt_wfile= NULL;
 static const char *opt_rfile= NULL;