• Preeti U Murthy's avatar
    cpufreq: Allow stop CPU callback to be used by all cpufreq drivers · 789ca243
    Preeti U Murthy authored
    Commit 367dc4aa ("cpufreq: Add stop CPU callback to
    cpufreq_driver interface") introduced the stop CPU callback for
    intel_pstate drivers. During the CPU_DOWN_PREPARE stage, this
    callback is invoked so that drivers can take some action on the
    pstate of the cpu before it is taken offline. This callback was
    assumed to be useful only for those drivers which have implemented
    the set_policy CPU callback because they have no other way to take
    action about the cpufreq of a CPU which is being hotplugged out
    except in the exit callback which is called very late in the offline
    process.
    
    The drivers which implement the target/target_index callbacks were
    expected to take care of requirements like the ones that commit
    367dc4aa addresses in the GOV_STOP notification event. But there
    are disadvantages to restricting the usage of stop CPU callback
    to cpufreq drivers that implement the set_policy callbacks and who
    want to take explicit action on the setting the cpufreq during a
    hotplug operation.
    
    1.GOV_STOP gets called for every CPU offline and drivers would usually
    want to take action when the last cpu in the policy->cpus mask
    is taken offline. As long as there is more than one cpu in the
    policy->cpus mask, cpufreq core itself makes sure that the freq
    for the other cpus in this mask is set according to the maximum load.
    This is sensible and drivers which implement the target_index callback
    would mostly not want to modify that. However the cpufreq core leaves a
    loose end when the cpu in the policy->cpus mask is the last one to go offline;
    it does nothing explicit to the frequency of the core. Drivers may need
    a way to take some action here and stop CPU callback mechanism is the
    best way to do it today.
    
    2. We cannot implement driver specific actions in the GOV_STOP mechanism.
    So we will need another driver callback which is invoked from here which is
    unnecessary.
    
    Therefore this patch extends the usage of stop CPU callback to be used
    by all cpufreq drivers as long as they have this callback implemented
    and irrespective of whether they are set_policy/target_index drivers.
    The assumption is if the drivers find the GOV_STOP path to be a suitable
    way of implementing what they want to do with the freq of the cpu
    going offine,they will not implement the stop CPU callback at all.
    Signed-off-by: default avatarPreeti U Murthy <preeti@linux.vnet.ibm.com>
    Acked-by: default avatarViresh Kumar <viresh.kumar@linaro.org>
    Signed-off-by: default avatarRafael J. Wysocki <rafael.j.wysocki@intel.com>
    789ca243
cpufreq.c 64.3 KB