• Roland Dreier's avatar
    target: Check sess_tearing_down in target_get_sess_cmd() · bc187ea6
    Roland Dreier authored
    Target core code assumes that target_splice_sess_cmd_list() has set
    sess_tearing_down and moved the list of pending commands to
    sess_wait_list, no more commands will be added to the session; if any
    are added, nothing keeps the se_session from being freed while the
    command is still in flight, which e.g. leads to use-after-free of
    se_cmd->se_sess in target_release_cmd_kref().
    
    To enforce this invariant, put a check of sess_tearing_down inside of
    sess_cmd_lock in target_get_sess_cmd(); any checks before this are
    racy and can lead to the use-after-free described above.  For example,
    the qla_target check in qlt_do_work() checks sess_tearing_down from
    work thread context but then drops all locks before calling
    target_submit_cmd() (as it must, since that is a sleeping function).
    
    However, since no locks are held, anything can happen with respect to
    the session it has looked up -- although it does correctly get
    sess_kref within its lock, so the memory won't be freed while
    target_submit_cmd() is actually running, nothing stops eg an ACL from
    being dropped and calling ->shutdown_session() (which calls into
    target_splice_sess_cmd_list()) before we get to target_get_sess_cmd().
    Once this happens, the se_session memory can be freed as soon as
    target_submit_cmd() returns and qlt_do_work() drops its reference,
    even though we've just added a command to sess_cmd_list.
    
    To prevent this use-after-free, check sess_tearing_down inside of
    sess_cmd_lock right before target_get_sess_cmd() adds a command to
    sess_cmd_list; this is synchronized with target_splice_sess_cmd_list()
    so that every command is either waited for or not added to the queue.
    
    (nab: Keep target_submit_cmd() returning void for now..)
    Signed-off-by: default avatarRoland Dreier <roland@purestorage.com>
    Signed-off-by: default avatarNicholas Bellinger <nab@linux-iscsi.org>
    bc187ea6
target_core_transport.c 84.2 KB