• unknown's avatar
    Bug#23713 LOCK TABLES + CREATE TRIGGER + FLUSH TABLES WITH READ LOCK = deadlock · 87143063
    unknown authored
    This bug is actually two bugs in one, one of which is CREATE TRIGGER under
    LOCK TABLES and the other is CREATE TRIGGER under LOCK TABLES simultaneous
    to a FLUSH TABLES WITH READ LOCK (global read lock). Both situations could
    lead to a server crash or deadlock.
    
    The first problem arises from the fact that when under LOCK TABLES, if the
    table is in the set of locked tables, the table is already open and it doesn't
    need to be reopened (not a placeholder). Also in this case, if the table is
    not write locked, a exclusive lock can't be acquired because of a possible
    deadlock with another thread also holding a (read) lock on the table. The
    second issue arises from the fact that one should never wait for a global
    read lock if it's holding any locked tables, because the global read lock
    is waiting for these tables and this leads to a circular wait deadlock.
    
    The solution for the first case is to check if the table is write locked
    and upgraded the write lock to a exclusive lock and fail otherwise for non
    write locked tables. Grabbin the exclusive lock in this case also means
    to ensure that the table is opened only by the calling thread. The second
    issue is partly fixed by not waiting for the global read lock if the thread
    is holding any locked tables.
    
    The second issue is only partly addressed in this patch because it turned
    out to be much wider and also affects other DDL statements. Reported as
    Bug#32395
    
    
    mysql-test/r/trigger.result:
      Add test case result for Bug#23713
    mysql-test/r/trigger_notembedded.result:
      Add test case result for Bug#23713
    mysql-test/t/trigger.test:
      Add test case for Bug#23713
    mysql-test/t/trigger_notembedded.test:
      Add test case for Bug#23713
    sql/mysql_priv.h:
      Locally export wait_while_table_is_used and name_lock_locked_table
      and add flag to mysql_ha_rm_tables to signal that LOCK_open is locked.
    sql/sql_base.cc:
      Introduce name_lock_locked_table function and match
      close_old_data_files function declaration and definition.
    sql/sql_handler.cc:
      Add flag to mysql_ha_rm_tables to signal that LOCK_open is locked.
    sql/sql_rename.cc:
      Fix mysql_ha_rm_tables caller.
    sql/sql_table.cc:
      Export wait_while_table_is_used and assert that LOCK_open is locked
      and fix mysql_ha_rm_tables caller.
    sql/sql_trigger.cc:
      Upgrade write locked tables to a exclusive lock and fail if
      the table is not write locked. Also, don't wait for the global
      read lock if under LOCK TABLES.
    87143063
trigger.result 61.9 KB